Subscription Trap

Deceiving users into subscribing to a recurring service without fully
grasping the ongoing commitment, often making cancellation difficult

Insights

Key Research Takeaways*

*The reported insights solely reflect instances of a single variant of subscription trap (i.e., "Freemium Fallout"). The study did not analyse post-subscription flows and therefore the presence of the other variant “Roach Motel”, was not detected.

Prevalence

Less than 5

of the applications studied used Subscription Trap in their
designs. It was one of the least observed Deceptive Patterns

Industry

Streaming Services

showed some of the few instances of Subscription Trap

App User Flow

Subscribing Journey

is where Subscription Trap was commonly observed

*The reported insights solely reflect instances of a single variant of subscription trap (i.e., "Freemium Fallout"). The study did not analyse post-subscription flows and therefore the presence of the other variant “Roach Motel”, was not detected.

Understanding Subscription Trap

Have you ever tried to sign
up for a free trial but had to provide your credit card details?

Understanding Subscription Trap

Businesses use free trials to convert inattentive users to paid subscribers, relying on a lack of reminders and complex cancellation flows

Definition

A pattern that businesses employ to trick users into signing up for a recurring subscription by obscuring terms and making cancellation difficult in order to generate recurring revenue

Variants

Ways in which businesses utilise
Subscription Trap

Variant 1

Freemium Fallout

User needs to provide payment details, or authorisation
for auto debits, in order to avail a free trial.

How does it affect users?

There is a risk users forget to cancel their subscription
before the trial ends, resulting in unintended charges.

Variant 2

Roach Motel

Making cancellation of a paid subscription impossible or a complex and lengthy process.

How does it affect users?

Inability or difficulty to unsubscribe leads to frustration

and unintended charges.

Ethical Alternatives

Ways in which design can address

Subscription Trap

LinkedIn
LinkedIn

Upfront Costs or Terms

Clearly present all renewal terms and costs upfront, ensuring users are fully aware of the subscription's renewal policy.

Playstation
Playstation

Value-First Experience

Provide a true free trial with full access to features before any charges, ensuring users experience value without hidden costs.

Need more Inspiration?

View 50+ Ethical Alternatives to
Privacy Deception and other Deceptive Patterns